Hillsborough County Lawsuit
When Medical Devices Are Mishandled: One Florida Family’s Devastating Stroke Case
When hospitals and doctors use advanced life-saving devices, patients place their trust—and their lives—in their hands. But when that trust is broken due to medical negligence, the results can be catastrophic.
That’s exactly what happened to a Florida mother in her 30s who suffered a massive stroke after a cardiologist allegedly repositioned a heart pump without following basic safety protocols. Now, she and her family are suing for medical malpractice.
A Promising Recovery
Turned into a Medical Emergency
The patient was first admitted to the hospital with severe shortness of breath and heart failure. Doctors placed her on VA-ECMO, a form of life support, and inserted an Impella device—a mechanical pump designed to support her heart and improve blood flow. Things were looking up. She was weaned off ECMO and breathing on her own. But just hours later, her condition took a dramatic turn.
According to the lawsuit, the Impella device slipped out of position. Instead of being in the left ventricle of the heart, it was found in the aorta—a dangerous and abnormal placement. Rather than confirming the Impella’s position with imaging tools like echocardiography or fluoroscopy, as required by the device’s instructions, the cardiologist moved the device blindly, without proper guidance or a guidewire.
The result? The device traveled into a major artery that feeds blood to the brain. Minutes later, the woman suffered a stroke. She lost the ability to move the left side of her body and could no longer speak.
Emergency Surgery Couldn’t Undo the Damage
Surgeons worked quickly to remove the device and restore blood flow to her brain. But the damage had already been done. A follow-up MRI showed a large stroke in the right side of her brain, leaving her with permanent neurological damage and serious physical impairments.
This case is now at the center of a medical malpractice lawsuit in Hillsborough County, Florida.
Legal Claims: Allegations of Medical Negligence and Hospital Liability
The lawsuit includes two major claims:
Count I: Medical Negligence
The cardiologist is accused of:
- Repositioning the Impella device without using imaging
- Failing to follow the device’s safety instructions
- Ignoring the standard of care for similar procedures
Count II: Hospital Liability (Vicarious Liability)
Because the cardiologist was employed by the hospital, the hospital is also being held legally responsible for his actions during the procedure.
A Family’s Life Changed Forever
This stroke has had a devastating impact:
- The woman now lives with permanent disabilities, pain, and limited mobility.
- Her husband has taken on the role of full-time caregiver and has lost the companionship and support of his wife.
- Their two young children face growing up with a mother who is no longer able to care for them the way she once could.
What This Case Teaches Us About Medical Device Misuse
This heartbreaking case highlights a critical issue in modern healthcare: the misuse of advanced medical devices like the Impella can have life-altering consequences when safety protocols are ignored.
Hospitals and medical providers must follow strict standards of care—especially when handling powerful devices meant to support or replace vital body functions. When they don’t, and a patient is seriously harmed, they can be held accountable in a court of law.
How Can We Help?
"*" indicates required fields
Proven.
Trusted.
Medical Malpractice
Wronful Death
Serious Personal Injury
What Our Clients Say
I highly recommend Paul Trial Group for your legal matters. Working with their team was really an exceptional experience even as I was going thru much duress.?Working with David Paul office you will get honesty, integrity and the truth.
- Laura A.
Mr. Murphy provided excellent service. With his assistance, I finally got the closure I needed for an otherwise emotionally stressful event. I highly recommend this firm and Mr. Murphy .
- D. (former client)
I have had a professional relationship with David Paul for over a decade. Recently, I have worked mostly with Scott Murphy. I have found the attorneys to be experienced, thorough, intelligent, insightful, diligent, personable, and committed. I recommend this firm and its attorneys very highly, and without reservation.
- Sidney A.
David Paul represented me in a personal injury case. I feel so fortunate and blessed that I had them in my corner. They were overwhelmingly prepared in every stage of my case. They take a limited number of cases so that they can dedicate their time to you legally, as well as personally. My family & I can’t say enough positive things about him!
- John D.
David Paul and Olivia Kronenberg not only represented our family, they did also so with a very personal approach. They were extremely thorough and methodical in their investigation and how they presented our case. It was not a quick process, but they made it easy and painless. They kept us advised on every update. Our settlement was just, and we were rewarded with closure on my wife’s death.
- Skip Banfell
My attorney, Olivia, eased any worries and made an extremely emotional and stressful situation go as smoothly as possible. Everyone I worked with treated me like a friend, not just a client.
- Stan Stevens
This firm valued me as a person not just a client, they respected my wishes, concerns, questions and answers.
- Fredericka Epps
A very professional and great team that was amazing in helping me and my family through some really hard times. I never really trusted lawyers until I worked with Dave and Olivia and now I feel like we are more like family.
- Michelle
I absolutely love Olivia! She was transparent, honest, helpful, and treated my case the same way she would treat it if it were her family.
- Savanna Whidden
Philip Moring and his staff were highly professional, accommodating and a pleasure to work with. They always showed knowledge and thoroughness, while also being efficient and getting straight to the point. They made the entire experience pleasant, and I would highly recommend them if you or a loved one needs a competent and personable lawyer.
- Mary D.
How can we help?
If you believe something went wrong,
we can help you understand your options
Not every case is viable, and we are honest about that. If we believe we can help,
we will tell you. If not, we will explain why.
24 Hours / 7 Days a Week